Crimes against persons
In short
An investigation for homicide or murder is the most serious situation anyone can face in criminal proceedings. The sentences are very long, pre-trial detention is frequently sought and every word said in the first few hours carries weight throughout the proceedings.
Homicide (homicidio) is killing another person (article 138 of the Criminal Code). Murder (asesinato) is killing where any of the following circumstances are present (article 139):
The difference between the two classifications means years in prison, and it is often decided in the technical argument over whether or not there was treachery.
If the events occur between people who are or have been partners, the case falls within the scope of gender-based violence, which we deal with in our specialist section.
| Offence | Article | Penalty provided |
|---|---|---|
| Homicide | 138.1 | Prison from 10 to 15 years |
| Homicide with circumstances under art. 140.1 or combined with an assault on a public authority | 138.2 | Penalty one degree higher (from 15 years and 1 day to 22 years and 6 months) |
| Murder | 139.1 | Prison from 15 to 25 years |
| Murder with more than one circumstance | 139.2 | Penalty in its upper half |
| Murder of a child under 16 or a particularly vulnerable person, following a sexual offence, by a member of a criminal organisation, or of more than two people | 140 | Reviewable permanent imprisonment (prisión permanente revisable) |
| Homicide through gross negligence | 142.1 | Prison from 1 to 4 years |
| Homicide through less serious negligence | 142.2 | Fine of 3 to 18 months |
If negligent homicide is committed with a vehicle, loss of the driving licence is added; with a firearm, loss of the right to possess one; and if it is professional negligence, disqualification from the profession (art. 142). People convicted of homicide or murder may also be placed under supervised release after prison (art. 140 bis).
These offences take a long time to become time-barred: twenty years where the maximum penalty is fifteen or more years in prison, as is the case for homicide and murder (art. 131).
The investigation is led by the Investigation Section of the Court of First Instance (Sección de Instrucción del Tribunal de Instancia, formerly the investigating court) where the events took place. If the case goes ahead, the trial for completed homicide or murder takes place before a Jury Court (Tribunal del Jurado) at the Provincial Court (Audiencia Provincial) (articles 1.2 and 5.1 of the Jury Act, Ley Orgánica 5/1995). Attempted homicide and negligent homicide do not go before a jury: they are tried by professional judges. A jury of citizens decides on the facts, and that requires the defence to be prepared differently: clarity, consistency and evidence that can be understood.
During the investigation, the judge may order pre-trial detention, which the law permits for offences punishable by two or more years in prison when there is a risk of absconding, destroying evidence or reoffending (art. 503 of the Criminal Procedure Act, Ley de Enjuiciamiento Criminal). That decision can be appealed, and having it reviewed is a priority from day one.
If there is a conviction, we also support you while the sentence is served: prison leave, grade classification and parole, through our prison law practice.
The relatives of a deceased person can join the proceedings as a private prosecutor (acusación particular). This gives them their own voice: they propose evidence, take part in the questioning, can seek a more serious classification than the public prosecutor and claim the compensation they are entitled to. In a jury trial, a well-prepared prosecution makes the difference.
If the death occurred in a road traffic or workplace accident, the case may be dealt with as negligent homicide. Here too it is important to act quickly to secure the technical evidence: the police report, accident reconstruction, labour inspection reports or medical records. We explain each step of the proceedings clearly, what the time limits are and what you can expect, so that you do not have to make decisions blindly at such a difficult time.
Homicide is killing another person and is punishable by ten to fifteen years in prison. It is murder where there is treachery, price or reward, cruelty or the aim of facilitating or concealing another offence, and the penalty rises to fifteen to twenty-five years. In some cases under article 140 of the Spanish Criminal Code the penalty is reviewable permanent imprisonment.
If the negligence is gross, the penalty is one to four years in prison (art. 142.1 of the Criminal Code), plus loss of the driving licence if a vehicle was involved. If it is less serious, the penalty is only a fine of three to eighteen months. Distinguishing between the two types of negligence is key to the defence.
Homicide and murder are tried by a Jury Court sitting at the Alicante Provincial Court, under the Jury Act. Beforehand, the investigation is led by the Investigation Section of the Court of First Instance where the events took place. Attempted homicide and negligent homicide do not go before a jury: they are tried by professional judges.
Yes, it is possible. The law permits pre-trial detention for offences punishable by two or more years in prison when there is a risk of absconding, destroying evidence or reoffending. The defence can oppose it at the hearing, propose alternative measures such as regular reporting to court or surrender of the passport, and appeal the order if it is made.
Homicide and murder become time-barred after twenty years, because their maximum penalty is fifteen or more years in prison (art. 131 of the Criminal Code). The period is interrupted when proceedings are brought against a specific person. Homicide through gross negligence, with a maximum penalty of four years, becomes time-barred after five.
If all the requirements are met, there is no criminal liability: a prior unlawful aggression, reasonable necessity of the means used to prevent or repel it, and lack of sufficient provocation on your part (article 20.4 of the Spanish Criminal Code). If there was an aggression but your response was excessive, an incomplete defence may be found, and the court must impose a penalty one or two degrees lower (arts. 21.1.ª and 68). Every detail counts, which is why you should prepare your first statement with a lawyer.
Under article 140 of the Spanish Criminal Code, it is imposed for murder when the victim is under sixteen or particularly vulnerable because of age, illness or disability; when the crime follows an offence against sexual freedom committed against the victim; or when the offender belongs to a criminal group or organisation. It is also imposed on anyone convicted of murdering more than two people.
The court can only suspend it and grant parole when the prisoner has served twenty-five years, is in third degree and there is a favourable prognosis for social reintegration, under article 92 of the Spanish Criminal Code (with longer periods in the cases of art. 78 bis). Once that time has been served, the court must check the requirements at least every two years. The suspension lasts five to ten years.
Less than for a completed homicide. Article 62 of the Spanish Criminal Code imposes for an attempt the penalty one or two degrees lower than that of the completed offence, depending on the danger involved in the attempt and how far its execution had progressed. As homicide is punishable by ten to fifteen years, the attempt may, depending on the case, fall into a clearly lower range. The difference between one and two degrees is a key defence issue.
It can be reduced. Acting on causes or stimuli so powerful that they produced a fit of rage, blinding passion or a similar emotional state is a mitigating circumstance (article 21.3 of the Spanish Criminal Code). If it is the only circumstance, the penalty for homicide is imposed in its lower half, that is, between ten years and twelve years and six months in prison (arts. 66.1.1.ª and 138.1). If it is considered highly qualified or occurs together with other mitigating circumstances, it can go down one or two degrees (art. 66.1.2.ª).
Because homicide carries a penalty of more than three years, pre-trial detention ordered because of a risk of flight, of reoffending or of acting against the victim cannot exceed two years, with a single extension of up to two more years if the trial cannot be held earlier (article 504.2 of the Spanish Criminal Procedure Act, LECrim). If it was ordered to prevent evidence from being hidden or destroyed, the limit is six months (art. 504.3). All that time is deducted from the sentence (art. 58 of the Spanish Criminal Code).
It depends on how you progress in prison. With sentences of more than five years, the court may order that you cannot access open prison (third degree) until you have served half (article 36.2 of the Spanish Criminal Code). Prison leave may come after serving a quarter (art. 47.2 of the Spanish General Prison Act). Parole requires third degree, good conduct and having served three quarters, or two thirds if you have carried out work or training activities (art. 90 of the Spanish Criminal Code). Time spent in pre-trial detention is deducted (art. 58 of the Spanish Criminal Code).
The material and non-material loss they have suffered. Article 113 of the Spanish Criminal Code establishes that compensation covers not only the harm caused to the injured party but also that caused to their relatives or third parties. The amount depends on the relationship and the circumstances of each case. Relatives can join the proceedings as private prosecutors to claim it and defend their interests at trial.
It can reduce it. Article 21.4 of the Spanish Criminal Code treats as a mitigating circumstance having confessed the offence to the authorities before learning that court proceedings are being brought against you. If you already knew you were under investigation, that mitigating circumstance does not apply as such, although cooperation may be taken into account in other ways. Before turning yourself in, you should talk to a lawyer to prepare properly how and to whom to do it.
Helping someone who has committed a homicide to evade the investigation or the police search, or hiding the body, the weapon or the evidence, is the offence of concealment (encubrimiento), punishable by six months to three years in prison (article 451 of the Spanish Criminal Code). However, article 454 exempts from that penalty anyone who conceals their spouse or stable partner, ascendants, descendants, siblings or in-laws in those degrees. The exemption does not cover helping them to benefit financially from the offence.
Do you need help now?
On this page
Related services
Areas we cover
We handle criminal cases throughout the province of Alicante, wherever you live and whichever court is handling your case. These are some of the towns where we work most often:
AlicanteElcheSan Vicente del RaspeigSant Joan d’AlacantEl CampelloMutxamelBenidormTorreviejaAlcoyDeniaCalpeAnd any other town in the province
Foreigners and tourists
Gender violence