Stages of the proceedings
In short
A false report is not just any complaint that ends up being dismissed. The Criminal Code punishes anyone who, knowing it to be false or with reckless disregard for the truth, attributes to another person acts which, if true, would constitute a criminal offence, provided they do so before a judicial or administrative official with a duty to investigate them: a judge, a public prosecutor or the police (Article 456.1).
Three elements are therefore required:
What is not a false report: reporting in good faith acts that later cannot be proved, mistakenly identifying someone without intending to harm them, or describing events inaccurately. Reporting a crime is a right, and the law does not punish mistakes but allegations made knowing they are lies or with complete indifference as to whether they are true.
There are related offences that should be distinguished:
The penalty for a false report depends on the seriousness of the offence that was falsely alleged (Article 456.1 of the Criminal Code):
| Offence falsely alleged | Penalty |
|---|---|
| Serious offence | Six months to two years’ imprisonment and a fine of twelve to twenty-four months |
| Less serious offence | Fine of twelve to twenty-four months |
| Minor offence | Fine of three to six months |
Perjury is punishable by six months to two years’ imprisonment and a fine of three to six months. If it is committed against the accused in criminal proceedings, the penalty rises to one to three years’ imprisonment and a fine of six to twelve months, and if a conviction resulted from that testimony, the penalties one degree higher are imposed (Article 458).
Slander is punishable by six months to two years’ imprisonment or a fine of twelve to twenty-four months if it is spread publicly and, otherwise, by a fine of six to twelve months (Article 206). It can only be prosecuted by private criminal action brought by the person harmed (Article 215) and becomes time-barred after one year (Article 131).
In addition to the penalty, the offender must pay compensation for the damage and loss caused, including non-pecuniary damage (Articles 110 and 116 of the Criminal Code).
This is the point that raises the most questions. The law provides that no action may be taken against the person who made the report until there is a final judgment or a final order dismissing or closing the case in which the allegation was made (Article 456.2).
Once that case has ended, there are two routes:
It is important to understand that a dismissal or an acquittal does not in itself prove that the report was false. It may be because there was insufficient evidence. For a conviction for making a false report, it must be shown that the person making it knew that what they said was untrue or acted with reckless disregard for the truth. That is why we study the whole case file before recommending a private criminal action.
If you have just received a summons or been arrested for something you have not done, the priority is not the private criminal action: it is defending yourself properly in the open case. A sound defence at that stage is also the foundation for any later action.
In the meantime: don’t contact the complainant, don’t delete anything from your phone and don’t post anything about the case.
Gender-based violence proceedings have their own rules and courts; we deal with them in our section on gender violence.
When the case has ended in a final dismissal or a final acquittal, we review whether there are grounds to take action:
It is not advisable to let time pass after the dismissal or acquittal: these offences are also subject to limitation periods. Every case is different; after reviewing yours we give you a personalised written quote.
Experience in high-profile cases. Celeste Pérez Bleda has defended people facing criminal complaints in cases covered by the media, and explained on Cadena SER (2017) why the complaint against her client lacked consistency.
It depends on the offence that was falsely alleged. If it was a serious offence, six months to two years’ imprisonment and a fine of twelve to twenty-four months; if it was less serious, a fine of twelve to twenty-four months; and if it was minor, a fine of three to six months (Article 456.1 of the Criminal Code). In addition, compensation must be paid for the damage caused.
You can do so once the dismissal or judgment is final (Article 456.2 of the Criminal Code). But the dismissal does not in itself show that the report was false: it must be proved that the complainant knew they were lying or acted with reckless disregard for the truth. We study the case file to assess whether there are sufficient grounds.
With objective evidence that contradicts the account: complete messages, call logs, locations, camera footage, documents or witnesses. The complainant’s contradictions and possible motives also count. What matters is gathering and preserving that evidence from the outset, even before making a statement in the case opened against you.
In both cases someone is falsely accused of a crime. A false report is made before an authority that must investigate, such as a judge, a public prosecutor or the police (Article 456). Slander is committed outside that setting, for example on social media; it can only be prosecuted by private criminal action brought by the person harmed and becomes time-barred after one year.
Yes. If the person who made the report is convicted, they are also civilly liable for the damage and loss caused, which may include defence costs, financial losses and non-pecuniary damage (Articles 110 and 116 of the Criminal Code). The claim is normally made in the same criminal proceedings, as private prosecutor.
No, if you acted in good faith. Article 456 of the Spanish Criminal Code requires the accusation to be made knowing it was false or with reckless disregard for the truth. The fact that a complaint ends up dismissed or with an acquittal does not in itself make it false: it must be shown that the complainant knew that what they were saying was untrue or acted with reckless disregard for checking it.
It can be. Article 456.1 of the Spanish Criminal Code does not require the accusation to be made before a judge: it is enough for it to be made before a judicial or administrative official with a duty to investigate the facts. The judicial police have precisely the obligation to investigate public offences and identify those responsible (art. 282 of the Spanish Criminal Procedure Act, LECrim).
Yes. Article 456.2 of the Spanish Criminal Code provides that the judge or court that heard the case will order proceedings to be brought ex officio against the complainant when that case reveals sufficient evidence of falsehood, without prejudice to your own right to report them. However, this can only be done after the final judgment or the final order dismissing or closing the original proceedings.
Yes, it is the offence of simulating a crime (simulación de delito). Article 457 of the Spanish Criminal Code punishes with a fine of six to twelve months anyone who, before a judicial or administrative official with a duty to investigate, reports a non-existent offence or pretends to be a victim of one, triggering legal proceedings. If there is also an attempt to collect an insurance payout, other offences, such as fraud, may also apply.
First, defend yourself in those proceedings: you cannot take action against the person who reported you until there is a final judgment or dismissal in your favour (article 456.2 of the Spanish Criminal Code). You have the right to know the facts, see the case file before making a statement and not make a statement (article 118 of the Spanish Criminal Procedure Act, LECrim). Keep messages, locations and witnesses, and do not contact the complainant. If you are summoned, see what to do as a person under investigation.
It is the offence of perjury (falso testimonio). Article 458 of the Spanish Criminal Code punishes it with six months to two years in prison and a fine of three to six months, and, if the false statement is made against the accused in a criminal case, with one to three years in prison and a fine of six to twelve months. If a conviction results from the testimony, the penalties are even higher.
Yes, it can happen. At the beginning the judge does not know whether the complaint is true and, in offences such as injury, threats or coercion, may prohibit you, as a precautionary measure, from approaching or communicating with the complainant if they consider it strictly necessary (article 544 bis of the Spanish Criminal Procedure Act, LECrim). You must comply with it even if it is unfair, because breaching it is another offence, and appeal against it through your lawyer.
It depends. The offence requires attributing to someone acts that would be an offence, knowing they are false or with reckless disregard for the truth (article 456 of the Spanish Criminal Code). A subjective assessment or an imprecise memory is not normally enough; inventing a blow or a threat that never happened can be. The penalty ranges from a fine to six months to two years in prison if what was alleged was a serious offence.
Yes, if it is done with violence or intimidation. Article 464 of the Spanish Criminal Code punishes with one to four years in prison and a fine of six to twenty-four months anyone who tries in this way to influence a complainant, party, person under investigation, lawyer, expert or witness to change their conduct in the proceedings, with the penalty in its upper half if they succeed. It also punishes reprisals for having taken part in court proceedings.
It may happen if they joined the proceedings as a prosecuting party. Article 240 of the Spanish Criminal Procedure Act (LECrim) allows a private complainant or civil claimant to be ordered to pay costs when the case file shows that they acted recklessly or in bad faith, and prohibits imposing costs on an acquitted defendant. If the complainant was not a party, the costs of your defence would have to be claimed by other means, for example in proceedings for false accusation.
Do you need help now?
On this page
Related services
Areas we cover
We handle criminal cases throughout the province of Alicante, wherever you live and whichever court is handling your case. These are some of the towns where we work most often:
AlicanteElcheSan Vicente del RaspeigSant Joan d’AlacantEl CampelloMutxamelBenidormTorreviejaAlcoyDeniaCalpeAnd any other town in the province