Public safety, public order and other offences
In short
Article 31 bis of the Criminal Code (Código Penal) allows a legal entity – whether a trading company, an association or a foundation – to be convicted in two situations:
The company’s liability is independent of that of the individual. It can be established even if the specific perpetrator has not been identified or proceedings could not be brought against them (article 31 ter). If both are fined, the court must adjust the amounts so that the total is not disproportionate.
The State, regional, local and institutional public administrations, regulatory bodies, public agencies and public business entities, and other entities exercising public powers are excluded (article 31 quinquies).
A company is only liable for offences where the Criminal Code expressly provides for it. Among the most relevant for any business are:
All penalties for legal entities are classed as serious. Article 33.7 lists the following:
| Penalty | Legal limit |
|---|---|
| Daily-rate or proportional fine | Depending on each offence |
| Dissolution | Permanent loss of legal personality |
| Suspension of activities | Up to 5 years |
| Closure of premises and establishments | Up to 5 years |
| Ban on carrying out the activities in which the offence was committed | Temporary, up to 15 years, or permanent |
| Disqualification from receiving subsidies, contracting with the public sector and tax benefits | Up to 15 years |
| Judicial administration | Up to 5 years |
To impose penalties other than a fine, the judge assesses whether they are necessary to prevent the criminal activity from continuing, their economic and social consequences, especially for employees, and the position of the person who failed in their duty of control (article 66 bis). Note: temporary closure, suspension of activities and judicial administration can be ordered as interim measures during the investigation.
Criminal compliance is the system that allows a company to be exempted from liability. If the offence is committed by a director or manager, exemption requires that, before the offence, the board had adopted and effectively implemented a suitable organisation and management model; that its supervision had been entrusted to a body with autonomous powers; that the perpetrator had fraudulently circumvented the model; and that there was no insufficient oversight (article 31 bis.2). If it is committed by an employee, it is enough to have adopted and effectively implemented an appropriate model (article 31 bis.4).
Under article 31 bis.5, the model must:
In small companies – those permitted to file an abridged profit and loss account – the board itself can take on the supervisory role (article 31 bis.3). If the requirements are only partially met, this is taken into account to reduce the penalty.
We design the model around the real risks of your business, not with generic templates: a model that exists only on paper does not provide exemption.
The Criminal Procedure Act (Ley de Enjuiciamiento Criminal) lays down its own rules. The summons is served at the registered office and the company is required to appoint a specially designated representative, a lawyer and a court representative (procurador) (article 119). That representative gives evidence on the company’s behalf, with the right to remain silent and not to testify against it (article 409 bis). It is advisable that this person is not someone being investigated individually in the same case, to avoid conflicts of interest. More information on our page about being summoned as a suspect.
After the offence, the company can only reduce its liability if, through its representatives (article 31 quater), it:
Penalties imposed on companies give rise to a criminal record, which is expunged under the general time limits. If dissolution or a permanent ban on activities is ordered, the entries are expunged after fifty years (article 136.3).
Yes. Article 31 bis of the Criminal Code allows companies, associations and foundations to be convicted of offences committed for their benefit by directors and managers, or by employees where there has been a serious failure in the duty of supervision. They are only liable for offences where the law expressly provides for it, such as fraud, tax fraud or money laundering.
The Criminal Code does not require every company to have one. But without an effective prevention model in place before the offence, the company cannot benefit from the exemption in article 31 bis. In practice, therefore, it is a company’s main defence tool in criminal proceedings.
Article 33.7 provides for fines, dissolution, suspension of activities for up to five years, closure of premises for up to five years, a temporary or permanent ban on activities, disqualification from contracting with the public sector and receiving public aid for up to fifteen years, and judicial administration for up to five years. A fine is the most common; the others require a specific assessment by the judge.
Yes. The law provides that in small companies – those permitted to file an abridged profit and loss account – the board itself can take on supervision of the model (article 31 bis.3). The model must be proportionate to the business and its real risks, without the structure a large corporation would need.
The company appoints a specially designated representative, who appears with the company’s lawyer (articles 119 and 409 bis of the Criminal Procedure Act). They have the right to remain silent and not to testify against the company. If they do not appear, the company is deemed to be exercising its right not to give evidence.
Article 31 bis of the Spanish Criminal Code provides for two routes: offences committed in the name or on behalf of the company, and for its direct or indirect benefit, by its representatives or those who can make decisions for it; and offences committed by employees for that same benefit when this has been possible because those responsible have seriously failed in their duties of supervision, monitoring and control. In addition, it is only liable in the cases expressly provided for in the Code.
Only those expressly provided for in the Spanish Criminal Code (art. 31 bis.1). These include, for example, fraud (art. 251 bis), money laundering (art. 302.2), offences against the Tax Agency and Social Security (art. 310 bis), bribery (art. 427 bis), computer and privacy offences (arts. 197 quinquies and 264 quater), drug trafficking (art. 369 bis) and environmental offences (art. 328).
Article 31 bis.5 of the Spanish Criminal Code requires the model to identify risk activities, establish decision-making protocols, manage financial resources to prevent offences, impose an obligation to report risks and breaches to the supervisory body, have a disciplinary system and be reviewed periodically, being amended when there are significant breaches or changes in the company. A generic document that is not actually applied does not meet these requirements.
It depends on the offence. It can be proportional, as in the tax offence, where it ranges from one to two times the amount defrauded (art. 310 bis of the Spanish Criminal Code), or based on daily rates: up to five years of fine with a daily rate of 30 to 5,000 euros (art. 50). Dissolution, suspension of activities or a ban on contracting with the public sector are also possible (art. 33.7). If the fine endangers the survival of the company or its jobs, it can be split into payments over up to five years (art. 53.5).
It does not exempt, but it can mitigate. Exemption requires the model to have been adopted and effectively implemented before the offence (art. 31 bis.2 and 4 of the Spanish Criminal Code). However, article 31 quater treats as a mitigating circumstance having established, before the start of the trial, effective measures to prevent and detect future offences. And if the requirements are only partly proven, they are also taken into account to reduce the penalty.
Article 31 quater of the Spanish Criminal Code only accepts as mitigating circumstances, in addition to subsequent compliance, that the company, through its representatives: confesses the offence to the authorities before knowing that proceedings are being brought against it; cooperates by providing new and decisive evidence at any stage of the proceedings; or repairs or reduces the damage before the trial. Choosing when and how to do this requires a well-thought-out defence strategy.
Yes. Under article 31 ter of the Spanish Criminal Code, the company’s liability can be enforced whenever it is established that the offence was committed by someone holding the posts or functions in article 31 bis, even if the specific person has not been identified or proceedings could not be brought against them. Nor does it disappear because that person has died or absconded. If both are fined, the judge must adjust the amounts.
Not necessarily. Article 130.2 of the Spanish Criminal Code establishes that transformation, merger, takeover or demerger does not extinguish criminal liability, which passes to the resulting entity, although the judge may moderate the penalty. Nor is it extinguished by a concealed or sham dissolution, which exists in any case when the activity continues with substantially the same customers, suppliers and employees.
Yes. Penalties imposed on legal entities are cancelled within the period that applies under the general rules of article 136 of the Spanish Criminal Code. Since all their penalties are considered serious (art. 33.7), that period is, in principle, ten years. If dissolution or a permanent ban on activities was ordered, the entry is not cancelled until fifty years have passed since the judgment became final. It is one more reason to invest in prevention.
Yes, as a precautionary measure. Article 33.7 of the Spanish Criminal Code allows the investigating judge to order, during the investigation, the temporary closure of premises or establishments, the suspension of the company’s activities and judicial administration of the company. These are measures that can paralyse the business, so the defence must step in from the outset to challenge their necessity and proportionality.
Do you need help now?
On this page
Related services
Areas we cover
We handle criminal cases throughout the province of Alicante, wherever you live and whichever court is handling your case. These are some of the towns where we work most often:
AlicanteElcheSan Vicente del RaspeigSant Joan d’AlacantEl CampelloMutxamelBenidormTorreviejaAlcoyDeniaCalpeAnd any other town in the province